It's been a wild few weeks hasn't it? At first everything was so blissfully black and white. Finally, here was something liberal and conservative Catholics could agree upon. We might debate among ourselves, but don't you dare mess with our 1st Amendment rights. Surely even good 'ol Thomas "I cut-and-paste my own version of the Bible" Jefferson would think this law was bogus.
But life became gray-colored. I read too many news articles, too many tweets, too many Facebook newsfeed debates. I got very discouraged - am I just a hateful idiot to the rest of the world? Is it even worth fighting over such a tiny financial technicality? Do I belong to a Church that wants to infringe on other people's rights?
Not really. By refusing to include insurance coverage for birth control and sterilization, the Church is hindering, but by no means stopping women from using such services. Catholic hospitals don't fire employees for having an IUD or vasectomy. Nor do Catholic universities
inspect student's purses to make sure The Pill isn't in there. People can do whatever they want with their paychecks on their own time. As the
greatly exaggerated, but real,
contraceptive habits of some Catholic women indicate, parish priests don't spend their days batting birth control from people's hands.
In a modern society where birth control is considered basic adult hygiene and an inalienable right, it's hard to explain the Catholic church's moral abhorrence to it. One of my Facebook friends compared conscience objections to a soup kitchen refusing to follow health codes, a basic part of living in a modern secular society. How do Catholics explain what a moral objection even feels like when modernity maintains few taboos?
The best comparison I could think up is the genital mutilation aka "female circumcision" practiced in some parts of Africa. If you lived in a country where it was accepted, you'd be sad to see your neighbors do it. Despite the side effect risks, they'd insist that it was essential for a young woman's healthy adolescence and happy marriage. You probably wouldn't judge them as terrible people, just be sad that they bought into an ideology that rejects the normal female body.
But if a law in that country required employee bonuses to include gift certificates for female genital mutilation, you'd want no part of that. Sure, some women need to go under the knife to remove tumors or ovarian cysts, but that's different. You'd refuse to enable something so repulsive to you. So the government rolls its eyes and offers an "accommodation." Good news - now your payroll admin company will just include those circumcision gift certs for free! Everyone wins!
Yeah right. You would't buy that. Neither would the payroll company.
Comparing contraception and sterilization to genital mutilation might seem extreme, but opposition to both comes from the same idea: respecting the female body. If you think the Church is all about controlling women, you should check out the
hundreds of Catholic mommy blog posts about Natural Family Planning. My church friends and I have heard about fertility cycles so much it's coming out of our ears. NFP is all cervixes and lady parts and menstrual cycles and how the female body works. When it's not controlled by chemicals. The Catholic Church is not just a bunch of old celibate guys in robes. It's also full of equally devoted women who feel empowered and self-aware, not oppressed.